Blog 3: Foundational Elements

 

Foundational Elements: First Nations

2nd Topic

First Nations

National Standards Bundle

National Theme 1: Culture: Learners will be able to explore and describe similarities and differences in the ways various cultural groups meet similar groups and concerns.

D2.Geo.8.3-5 Explain how human settlements and movements relate to the locations and use various natural resources


Bundle Defense

I paired the culture theme with the geography standard because this provides two different lenses for students to explore the compelling question. What makes a First Nation successful is the groups ability to work together as well as adapting to the environment and using their resources. 

Compelling Question

What factors led to the First Nations' success?

Compelling Question Defense

This question is academically challenging because there is not one outright answer. It applies to students because they have an understanding of what success is and what failure is. They also have studied other prior civilizations and can use that background knowledge to frame their thinking around what makes a Nation successful. 



Supporting Questions:

What resources did the First Nations use?
What power structures did the First Nations use in their communities?
How did the landscape impact the First Nations

Answer: The First Nations' appreciation and knowledge of nature, strong social structures, and their ability to adapt with the environment is what led to their success. Without one of these three key pieces, the First Nations most likely would not have been as successful. 


Comments

  1. Josie,

    Your explanation for pairing the Geography dimension and culture theme was awesome -- giving your students two different ways to look at your compelling question gives them that freedom to interpret it a little different from their classmates without getting too off track. The defense to your compelling question also explains this a little bit, as you said there is not one outright answer so your students will still be challenged and have to put thought into how they answer this question. Your supporting questions can be answered with one straight answer, which will definitely help your students stay on track to find an overall answer to the compelling question being proposed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Tabatha!

      Thank you! Yes, my plan was to make my supporting questions more tangible so students can have some concrete ideas about how the First Nations lived in order to answer the more abstract compelling question. Thanks for your thoughts!

      Delete
  2. Hi Josie!

    I think your standard and theme work well together in examining the first nations. The supporting questions you created pair well with the compelling questions, as they look at the resources, power structures and landscape of the first nations that led to the success. The answer you developed from the supporting question demonstrates how well the supporting question aid students to answer the compelling question. I think this topic and supporting questions go well with the grades 3-5 and challenges the students to examine the resources provided. Do you have an idea of how to introduce this compelling question to the students? Great post!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Sarah!

      Thanks for your feedback. I think this topic is a great time to move away from using the textbook. I know in my past classes at least, the textbook gave very little information on the First Nations on North America. I think this could be a good place to introduce this-- ask students if they know who was in America before Christopher Columbus. I might even ask them why people say Christopher Columbus discovered America. This could be a good time to introduce that topic at 4th grade.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blog #5 Final

Blog Post #1

Blog #4 Project Based Learning